Where is the Calgary Market going in 2012?

The good news is we are off to a good start this year!

It does look like we are in for an interesting year in Calgary this coming year. In the first quarter of 2012 we are seeing decent sales, and our inventory is growing slowly. We do need to keep an eye on the inventory levels as we may very well see a dramatic increase in the next few weeks. Last year many homes that were listed did not sell - many of those listings have been terminated or have expired. As a matter of fact, in analyzing communities across the city I have seen that rate as high as 50% - that means HALF of the homes that were listed last year DID NOT SELL! I suspect a good portion of those expired listings will be coming back on the market for the spring rush. I would also suggest that many of these Sellers are going to be more aggressive in their pricing, how they approach marketing their homes and how they deal with offers. This could set the pace for values right across the board.

There is also a huge inventory of properties that has been on the market for many months and many listings have been on for YEARS! I found one listing recently in Mount Pleasant that has been on for 1,170 consecutive days! How long can a Seller hold onto a property without sustaining considerable losses, both financially and otherwise? One of the best examples of this is a beautiful property out in Bearspaw that was purchased back in 2007 for $6.35 million, a real gem! Two and a half years later it came back on the market, listed for $5.35 million. It has been on the market ever since (849 days) and the listing price has been in steady decline. You can pick up this home today for $3.85 million!

Have prices dropped 40% since our peak in 2007? Absolutely not, this is an extreme case of a declining value and there are a select few buyers with a budget over $2 million... however, this is a reality jolt, and a true fact. It does go to show that we do need to be very cognizant of the current market... and where it is headed!

I would be cautious of how sustainable this new activity these first few weeks into 2012 is on a long term basis. In Calgary and the surrounding area we should be selling around 2,000 properties per month, a little higher late spring, and a bit less in the cold months. We have been below this plateau since August of last year. Perhaps that pent up demand will carry us through a couple of months in the spring, again we need to be very aware of why we see the higher sales, and how long we can sustain those numbers. The next three months will be paramount in seeing any kind of gain in values in the area. Typically we look at the official opening of the Stampede as the "hump" in the market… school is out, the summer is officially here and many Calgarians head to cottage country and to summer vacations.

Having said that, I would suggest that if you are considering selling this year, there is a narrow window of opportunity in the next couple of months to ride the wave of the buyers who have been sitting on the fence for the past six months or so. Once that pool of buyers dries up, we will probably see much of what we experienced through the past year, a lethargic pace at best.

If you are not considering selling your house in the next year or so, I would suggest we will do well in the next three to five years. Once things start to work themselves out with the global economy... our superior economic and political position and the location of Calgary will certainly make itself more and more apparent, and we should see a steady pace of future growth.

If you are considering buying in this market I would suggest this may very well be the best time in many years for a purchase. With interest rates at historical lows - and the opportunity to lock into these rates for long-term periods - there may not be a better time to move into a new home. The inventory of available homes typically is at its maximum in the next two or three months giving you LOTS of choice. That in combination with the softening attitudes of sellers in general will lead to a competitive and healthy marketplace.

I would be happy to discuss your posibilities with you, and to put together a strategy with you to help you achieve your goals. Please do visit my web pages to find out more about the market, and what we can do for you.

http://www.thenashgroup.ca/home.asp

Canada's Housing Bubble - An Accident Waiting to Happen

The Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives (CCPA) has just released its study "Canada's Housing Bubble: An Accident Waiting to Happen". This paper is certainly worth the read as it runs over a variety of potential scenarios we may be facing in the next few weeks, months and years.

My critisism of this study is the fact that the author is "predicting" one of these scenarios to happen in future. The over inflated prices HAVE happened in Calgary peaking in mid-2007. The question is - are we in the midst of one of these "bubbles" or about to enter one? Without a doubt, I believe we have been in this "correcting" mode for over three years. As that is the case, the next series of questions to address would pertain to understanding where we are within this price correction. Are we in the beginning, the middle or the end?

The Canadian housing market has shown remarkable resilience through the worldwide economic downturn and the recession of 2008, quickly regaining ground over the past year creating possible price bubbles in several Canadian hot zones, including Calgary. The study points out that the recent U.S. housing crash provides a stark example of what can go horribly wrong when housing prices are outside their historical norms. Although the Canadian and American banking and mortgage situations are very different, it is important to note what happened, and how it happened south of our border, "a similar crisis could potentially occur."

Canada is experiencing, for the first time in the last 30 years, a synchronized housing bubble across its six largest residential real estate markets. The paper puts together a variety of price adjustment scenarios wondering the odds of the bubble bursting, flaming out fast or slow, versus a slow price moderation - or market correction. Regardless of the road we take, this study certainly leads to the conclusion that we WILL see adjustments, whether fast or moderate changes.

Whether the crash is orderly, protracted, or sudden, seniors and new home buyers will certainly feel the effect of the changes the most. Those who purchased homes through high-ratio mortgages while prices were at their highest will find that they owe more on their homes than the value the market permits. Seniors who will be counting on selling their homes to make their retirement plans viable and can't wait a decade or so for prices to recover will be the most effected.

While the outlook seems dim, it is pointed out that those who hold real estate through the entire boom and bust would still see their property appreciate significantly despite the declines in the final years of these various scenarios. Often the process is quite lengthy, requiring a decade or more from beginning to end. In all of the bubbles examined in the paper, the new average price after the bubble burst is always higher than the initial starting point.

Real Estate July Statistics in Calgary

The Calgary Real Estate Board has released the latest statistics and the news is not good, but it is nothing we were not expecting. Last year, July saw 2,853 sales in Calgary and the surrounding area, which was actually quite high. July 2008 had 2,336 sales, July 2007 had 2,677 sales, July 2006 had 2,710 sales and in July 2005 - prior to our huge escalation in pricing - there were 2,723 sales. Regardless of how we look at it, we are extremely and dangerously low this year with only 1,683 sales in July. May and June also saw the lowest sales figures in comparison to May and June sales in the past five years.

Historically, August sees lower sales figures than May, June and July. We should also anticipate that sales will typically decrease the last third of the year due to the change in seasons. As a Seller, we need to pay very close attention to the sales figures over the next few months. The real estate market is one of the most pure forms of supply and demand, and as we see demand drop further, prices may also adjust suddenly and dramatically. Average sale prices have dropped 4% in the past month, which is quite concerning. Some economists have been predicting dramatic changes in pricing (see my blog) by the end of the year.

The question is… when can we expect the market to level out and start to increase again? Typically our "spring" market picks up the pace from the winter doldrums, however, we need to keep a close watch on some worrisome trends that will certainly effect our market. Most specifically, Calgary has seen a dramatic change in its growth. The Calgary Herald reported that our growth has slowed to a 26 year low (see the July 23rd edition.) More people left the city than arrived for the first time since 1992. Without a doubt, the fact our population growth is the lowest since 1984 is having a huge impact on our market right now. We are certainly in for some interesting months ahead.

If you have any questions or would like further clarification on any of this information, please do not hesitate to drop me a line.
________________________________________

News Release

Summer Cool Down Continues in Calgary Housing Market

Calgary, August 3, 2010 – The summer cool down in Calgary’s housing market continued in the month of July, according to figures released today by the Calgary Real Estate Board (CREB®).

The number of single family homes sold in July 2010 in the city of Calgary was down 42 per cent from the same time a year ago, and condominium sales saw a decrease of 44 per cent from the same time a year ago.

July 2010 saw 915 single family homes sold in the city of Calgary. This is a decrease of 14 per cent from 1,061 sales in June 2010. In July 2009, single family home sales totalled 1,585. The number of condominium sales for the month of July 2010 was 396. This was a decrease of 11 per cent from the 445 condominium transactions recorded in June 2010. In July 2009, condominium sales were 702.

“Calgary’s housing market is cooling off after its record-setting pace in the post-recession period. This slow-down is not all that surprising in the face of tighter mortgage regulations and rising interest rates. The post-recession rally we saw in the summer of 2009 was unique and that pace couldn’t be sustained,” says Sano Stante, president-elect of CREB®.

“The sense of urgency seen last summer, fall and winter in the lead-up to tighter mortgage-lending measures has diminished,” says Stante. “Rising mortgage rates and increased inventories will be the primary head-wind facing Calgary’s housing market, but improving job prospects will offer some tail winds in the latter half of 2010 and into 2011.”

The average price of a single family home in the city of Calgary in July 2010 was $464,655, showing a 4 per cent decrease from June 2010, when the average price was $481,964, and showing an increase of 6 per cent from July 2009, when the average price was $436,782. The average price of a condominium in the city of Calgary was $291,168, showing no significant change from June 2010, when the average price was $292,238 and a 2 per cent increase over last year, when the average price was $285,032. Average price information can be useful in establishing trends over time, but does not indicate actual prices in centres comprised of widely divergent neighbourhoods, or account for price differentials between geographical areas.

“We are seeing relative stability in our average and median prices for the Calgary market,” says Stante. “A gradual return to moderate interest rates will not trigger any kind of steep decline in prices in our housing market. Prices may soften in select markets where inventory has bulked up, but for the most part they will remain relatively sticky as the economy improves.”

“Nonetheless with the combination of historically low interest rates and a large inventory of homes, there are some great buys out there—particularly in areas where comparable stock is ample such as the condominium and multi-family market. This presents a great opportunity to get into the market or to trade up,” adds Stante.

The median price of a single family home in the city of Calgary for July 2010 was $400,000, showing a 5 per cent decrease from June 2010, when the median price was $418,900, and a 3 per cent increase from July 2009, when the median price was $390,000. The median price of a condominium in July 2010 was $268,000, showing a 1 per cent decrease from June 2010, when the median was $269,900. That’s up 2 per cent from July 2009, when the median price was $263,000.

All city of Calgary MLS® statistics include properties listed and sold only within Calgary’s city limits. The median price is the price that is midway between the least expensive and most expensive home sold in an area during a given period of time. During that time, half the buyers bought homes that cost more than the median price and half bought homes for less than the median price.

There was a slowdown in the number of Calgarians putting homes up for sale in the month of July. Single family listings in the city of Calgary added for the month of July totalled 1,942, a decrease of 29 per cent from June 2010 when 2,733 new listings were added, and showing a decrease of 7 per cent from July 2009, when 2,089 new listings came to the market.

Condominium new listings in the city of Calgary added for July 2010 were 890, down 18 per cent from June 2010, when the MLS® saw 1,084 condo listings coming to the market. This is a decrease of 3 per cent from July 2009, when new condominium listings added were 918.

“Indeed Alberta and Calgary’s economic recovery is lagging behind the rest of the country right now. But on the bright side we see this trend reversing itself as we move into 2011. We expect Alberta to lead in economic growth and recovery—outperforming much of the country in 2011,” says Stante.

To view the CREB statistics page, please visit the media page here:
Calgary Real Estate Statistics